Meetings and Events

MINUTES OF THE ORDINARY GENERAL MEETING
OF THE ASSOCIATION OF NATIONAL NUMBERING AGENCIES
 
HELD IN PRAGUE ON May 10 & 11, 2001
 
Host: Czech Securities Commission
Venue: Holiday Inn Hotel - Prague
 
Participants present
Mr Juan Carlos Falabella (JCF)
Caja De Valores S.A.
Argentina
Mr Norbert Leitgeb
Mr Gerald Kraft
Oesterreichische Kontrollbank AG.
Austria
Mr Léon Lambert (LL)
C.I.K. - BXS-Info
Belgium
Ms Nina Stoyanova
Bulgarian National Bank
Bulgaria
Mr Fran Daly
The Canadian Depository for Securities
Canada
Mr Josip Ivancic
Central Depository Agency Inc.
Croatia
Mr Nourredine Yous (NY)
Telekurs Financial Information Ltd
Switzerland
Ms Maria Petsa (MP)
Ms Aggeliki Frangou
Cyprus Stock Exchange
Cyprus
Ms Ruth Surgova (RS)
Czech Securities Commission
Czech Republic
Mr Georg Eisel (GE)
Mr Uwe Meyer (UM)
Wertpapier-Mitteilungen
Germany
Mr Niels W. Hougaard (NWH)
Vaerdipapircentralen
Denmark
Mr José Manuel Alonso (JMA)
Comision Nacional del Mercado de Valores
Spain
Mr Kimmo Koskinen (KK)
Finnish Central Securities Depository Ltd
Finland
Mr Alain Duhamel (AD)
Euroclear France
France
Mr Vagelis Tsekrekos
Central Securities Depository SA
Greece
Mr Terry Allison (TA)
London Stock Exchange
United Kingdom
Mr György Dudàs
Central Clearing House and Depositary (Budapest) Ltd
Hungary
Mr Fulvio Zugaro (FZ)
Ufficio Italiano del Cambi
Italy
Mr In Seok Park
Mr Kimyung Song
Korea Stock Exchange
Korea
Mr Dan Kuhnel (DK)
Clearstream Banking
Luxembourg
Mr Peter M. Bakker
Aex - Clearing and Depository N.V.
Netherlands
Ms Vigdis Diesen (VD)
Verdipapirsentralen
Norway
Mr Jyrki Leppänen
Interbolsa
Portugal
Ms Anna Duran
The National Securities Clearing Settlement Depository Corporation
Romania
Mr Mikhail Laufer
Ms Svetlana Romantsova
The National Depository Center
Russia
Ms Marianne Wainwright
VPC AB
Sweden
Ms Yeu-May Yu
Taiwan Stock Exchange Corporation
Taiwan
Ms Zeineb Slim
Sticodevam
Tunisia
Mr Osman Gunsel Topbas
Takasbank
Turkey
Mr Volodymyr Ulyanov (VU)
National Depository of Ukraine
Ukraine
Mr Jim Taylor (JT)
Mr Scott Preiss (SP)
Cusip Service Bureau
USA
Mr Danny Ooghe (DO)
Euroclear Bank S.A./N.V.
Belgium

Members represented by powers of attorney

  Australian Stock Exchange Australia
  Bolsa de Valores de Sao Paulo - Bovespa Brazil
  Indonesian Central Securities Depository Indonesia
  Tehran Stock Exchange Services Co Iran
  The Tel Aviv Stock Exchange Israel
  Kuwait Clearing Corporation Kuwait
  Central Depository Cy of Paskistan Paskistan
  National Depository for Securities Poland
  Stredisko Cennych Papierov AS Slovakia
  KDD Central Securities Clearing Corp. Slovenia
  Thailand Securities Depository Co. Ltd Thailand

1. Opening & Welcome

1.1       N. Hougaard (NH) welcomed delegates to the ANNA Ordinary General Meeting in Prague.

2. Roll call of Delegates

2.1      33 Members were present and 10 members were represented by proxy. 43 members (70,5%) of the membership were present or represented by proxy satisfying the quorum requirements of the Articles of Association.

3. Adoption of the Agenda

3.1      The agenda was adopted with the addition of a report from Nourredine Yous (NY) on the work of ISO/TC68/SC4/WG6:

- Report from the Chairman
- Financial report & forecast (ANNA & GIAM/ASB)
- ANNA Service Bureau - Implementation status
- Election of two Board Members
- Election process for the ASB Advisory Board
- Letters of Understanding - Status report
- Report from the Convenor of ANNA-WG2/ISIN User Group
- Report from other Working Groups (WGs) and Task Forces (TFs)
- Report from the Convenor of ISO/TC68/SC4/WG6
- Miscellaneous
- Next meeting
- Closure

3.2      Following NH's proposal, Terry Allison (TA) kindly accepted to draft the minutes of the meeting.

3.3      In the same manner, Nourredine Yous (NY) and Jyrki Leppanen (JL) were nominated as vote tellers to check the vote result on the various resolutions or elections.

4. Report from the Chairman

4.1      NH reported that, while one Board meeting had taken place in London so far this year, the Board and the Secretariat had been actively involved in the work surrounding the ANNA Service Bureau (ASB). As this was going to be covered in some detail later on, his comments would be limited.

5. Financial Report and Forecast
 
G. Eisel (GE) went through the following financial papers:
- The accounts for 2000
- The financial forecast for 2001
- Draft proposal for a new account structure for 2002
- Auditors Report from Tytgat & Arcelin

5.2           Resolution 1

The ANNA Board will produce itemised travel expenses for presentation at all futureGeneral Meetings, broken down into Board meetings and conferences attended while representing ANNA.
The resolution was adopted .

5.3          Resolution 2

The ANNA Board will report to the ANNA members on all conferences, showing reason for attending and achievement.
The resolution was adopted .

5.4            Resolution 3

The ANNA members adopt the Annual Accounts for 2000.
The resolution was adopted .

5.5            Resolution 4

The ANNA members give quitus to the ANNA Board members.
The resolution was adopted .

5.6            Resolution 5

The ANNA members accept the report issued by the external auditors Tytgat & Arcelin.
The resolution was adopted .

5.7            Resolution 6

The ANNA members agree the use of the surplus.
The resolution was adopted .

5.8            Resolution 7

The ANNA Board will produce a proposal on the issue of reimbursement of expenses for ANNA Board Members, Working Group Members and Task Force Members by the next General Meeting.
The resolution was adopted .

5.9            Resolution 8

The ANNA members approve a new account frame valid from January 1, 2002 in order to achieve more transparency and to follow the new organisational structure (ANNA Service Bureau). The official accounts maintained by Euronext will be adapted according to the new frame and to Belgium legal requirements.
The resolution was adopted .

5.10      L. Lambert (LL) proposed a new structure for future agenda points suggesting that a letter be sent to all members prior to the General Meeting, containing a written report from the Chairman and financial reports to include financial forecast for the next year. NH accepted the proposal and will implement for future meetings.

5.11      It was agreed that GE should produce a proposal for the distribution of revenue to NNAs from the ANNA Service Bureau to be presented at the next General Meeting.

6. ANNA Service Bureau - Implementation status

6.1        Task Force 16

6.1.1     N. Yous (NY) reviewed the work of TF16 and confirmed that the internal version of the ASB specifications had been checked by TF16 members and that most of the comments had been integrated.

6.1.2     Both J. Taylor (JT) and NY confirmed that both organisations had disaster recovery procedures in place that cover problems related to the ASB.

6.1.3     It was confirmed that the contract with Reardon Technology, covering the GIAM system, should probably cease on January 1, 2002, however the ANNA website maintenance still need to be discussed. A proposal will be presented by the Board at the next General Meeting.

6.1.4     NY thanked all members of TF16 for their hard work and commitment.

6.1.5     It was also confirmed that TF16 would cease as from July 1, 2001.

6.2        ASB demonstration

6.2.1     S. Preiss (SP) gave a demonstration to the members using a prototype of the product line ISIN Access of the ASB.

6.2.2     SP confirmed that coding and programming were on schedule for the July 1, 2001 live date.

6.2.3     SP reminded members that the ASB would need a download of members' GIAM data files in order to populate ASB. In order to avoid confusion regarding what is expected from members the following resolutions were voted:

ANNA resolves to retain July 1, 2001 as the start date for the ASB. NNAs agree to supply their ISIN masterfiles to the ASB before that date, subject to the following principals:
(a)     The ASB will resend their April 27, 2001 communication to all NNAs officially requesting their ISIN files, along with a letter informing NNAs what they are expected to supply and when.
(b)     NNAs may initially FTP their ISIN files as they do today for a period of 90 days without the header record and naming convention suggested in the ASB technical specifications.
(c)     The ASB will contact any non-participating or non-responsive NNAs to encourage submission of their files.
(d)     The ASB, under the guidance of TF16, will reconsider the proposed 6pm GMT "daily ISIN cut-off time" and report back to the Board by June 1, 2001 with its findings.
The resolution was adopted .

6.3        Bilateral Agreements

6.3.1     All ANNA members who will additionally require a bilateral agreement as well as the ASB contract have been asked to review this position as follows:

6.3.2       Resolution 10

The ANNA Board will send a letter to all NNAs together with the current ASB contract asking them to confirm by June 7, 2001 if they require any additional "terms and conditions" to be included into the ASB contract.
The resolution was adopted .

7. Election of two Board Members

7.1        On behalf of the Nomination Committee NH, LL and DO reminded the group that two positions were vacant on the Board and presented the only two candidates having received at least five nominations: The London Stock Exchange represented by Terry Allison and Euroclear France represented by Alain Duhamel. The election was held and the Members voted on the following resolutions:

7.2          Resolution 11

The ANNA Members re-elect the London Stock Exchange (represented by Terry Allison) for a period of three years ending after the Ordinary General Meeting approving the accounts for the fiscal year 2003.
The resolution was adopted.

7.3           Resolution 12

The ANNA Members re-elect Euroclear France (represented by Alain Duhamel) for a period of three years ending after the Ordinary General Meeting approving the accounts for the fiscal year 2003.
The resolution was adopted .

8. Election of the ASB Advisory Board

8.1            Resolution 13

The ANNA Members elected Takasbank (represented by Osman Topbas) for a period of four years ending after the Ordinary General Meeting approving the accounts for the fiscal year 2004.
The resolution was adopted .

8.2            Resolution 14

The ANNA Members elected Euronext Brussels (represented by Léon Lambert) for a period of three years ending after the Ordinary General Meeting approving the accounts for the fiscal year 2003.
The resolution was adopted .

8.3            Resolution 15

The ANNA Members elected Clearstream Banking (represented by Dan Kuhnel) for a period of two years ending after the Ordinary General Meeting approving the accounts for the fiscal year 2002.
The resolution was adopted .

8.4      Two ASB Advisory Board seats have also been appointed by the ANNA Board. Vaerdipapircentralen represented by Niels Hougaard as Chairman of ANNA together with Euroclear France represented by Alain Duhamel, Convenor of ANNA-WG2/ISIN User Group.

8.5       ANNA appointed delegates designated the Chairman of the ASB Advisory Board and Clearstream Banking represented by Dan Kuhnel (DK) was appointed as the first Chairman for a one year term.

8.6      It was also agreed that Takasbank represented by Osman Topbas shall chair the next period where ANNA appoints the Chairman.

9. Letters of Understanding – Status report

9.1       Uwe Meyer (UM) and NH commented on a report recently prepared by the ANNA Secretariat showing status of the various NNAs vis a vis several ANNA requirements (Annex E). It was agreed that the Substitute Numbering Agencies would follow-up on exceptions for their area of responsibility and would come back to members with a new status report, showing progress made, at the next General Meeting.

10. Report from the Convenor of ANNA-WG2/ISIN User Group

10.1      Alain Duhamel (AD) reported on the work of WG2 and the ISIN User Group. AD stated that a summary paper on the use of the MIC code would be issued in June and that the next meeting was being hosted by SWIFT in London. The ANNA membership will be kept informed accordingly.

10.2      AD reported that a minor revision was planned for ISO-6166 and would be presented by Euroclear Bank to WG2 members prior to being distributed to all ANNA members for comments. NY reminded members that any alterations to the standard, no matter how minor, would have to go the normal ISO revision process.

11. Reports from other Working Groups (WGs) and Task Forces (TFs)

11.1     Uwe Meyer (UM) reported on the work of WG1 and confirmed that 10 countries had signed ANNA partnership agreements. UM confirmed that discussions were taking place with China, Macedonia, Kazakhstan and the Eastern Caribbean Exchange about the implementation of ISIN in their countries.

11.2      UM said it was hoped that, by the end of the year, as a result of partnership agreements, 20 countries would be allocating ISINs who would otherwise not be able to.

12.  Report from the Convenor of ISO/TC68/SC4/WG6

12.1      NY gave presentation on the work of SC4-WG6 who are initially tasked with looking at ‘’Financial Instruments Short Descriptions’’.

13. Miscellaneous

13.2       Answering a question raised by NY, AD confirmed that Paris, Amsterdam and Brussels will implement the ISIN standard on the Euronext platform in 2002 together with the MIC code (ISO-10383 Market Identifier). AD added that the ISIN should also be used shortly for the settlement of domestic trades in France.

14. Next meeting

14.1      Juan Carlos Falabella from the Caja de Valores in Argentina has offered to host the next Extraordinary General Meeting in Buenos Aires on October 25 & 26, 2001.

14.2      In the same manner, the Central Securities Depository of Greece has offered to host the spring meeting of ANNA in 2002.

15.  Closure

15.1       NH expressed his thanks for the hospitality of the Czech Securities Commission and looked forward to welcoming members to Buenos Aires in October.